I was listening to a bit of NPR this morning and heard of another revealed memorist hoax. The half-white, half-native American gang member, drug dealer from South LA, Margaret B. Jones, is actually the all-white Margaret Seltzer from a flourishing suburb in northern Los Angeles. Her 'autobiography' chronicled her foster situation and eventual gang affiliation and thug shenanigans. All false. All complete fiction. Reportedly, a very well-written piece (many ravenous critics praised the newest unique, young memorist) and yet there is the rub because of her deceit and the rub of our culture's reaction.
I had originally been preoccupied with the hoax and hadn't even considered the fact that it probably doesn't matter a wit that she lied. The reasons for her fabrication is simple. To sell a large amount of novels there are certain culturally common interests the author must appeal to. Voyeurism is the tie that binds the population of Americans who are increasingly interested in documentary film, blogs, reality television, and autobiography. As Tim Rutten of the LA Times puts it, "We love tell-alls and publishers love money." He says that our insatiable desire for vicarious living has caused us to demand the most savage and urbane stories as long as it's the dirty little nuggets of truth.
A couple years ago James Frey was at the top of the memorist-fakers most-wanted list. He wildly embellished his run-in with the law in his book
A Million Little Pieces. Oprah's book club adored him; he was practically celebrity. Then it came out that he was not quite the overcomer of a life of hard drugs and crime that he said he was. I recently read an essay written by a fellow who had interviewed James Frey before the facts were revealed. He didn't really discuss why Frey would lie or how it could or could not be tolerated, but he wondered more about what autobiography even is.
Some of the most interesting points are made in the essay when he examines how people who write about what "actually" happened in their lives always seem to have the super human ability to remember. Conversations from decades and decades ago are relayed verbatim. Vivid details of memories occuring while the author was not of an age where memories are usually not captured.
That is all very fascinating to me. As of late I have been engrossed by creative nonfiction. I love the notion that facts and events can be written about in an enjoyable and creative manner. The art of essay. I want it.